Workers Comp Audit Preparation Guide

An audit ensures that the insurance company has correctly assessed your premiums, and it helps prevent underpayment or overpayment of workers’ compensation costs. Premium calculations are based on actual payroll and risk classifications, which reflect the nature of the work performed by employees. For example, if a company underreports its payroll by $100,000, it could lead to a substantial underpayment of premiums, impacting the insurance pool’s ability to cover claims. Audits review payroll records to confirm the amounts reported and verify the job classifications to ensure they are correct. This meticulous process helps prevent an estimated 10-20% of premium miscalculations, as reported by the Insurance Information Institute (III).

Depending on your location, your budget, and the size of your business, you may have a few options for workers’ comp insurance carriers. After reviewing the documents and information provided during the appointment, the auditor will finalize the audit results. Our team of friendly, knowledgeable auditors will guide the policyholder through every step of the final audit process to make it as simple and easy as possible. We recommend the policyholder keep their documents on hand during the audit in case there are any questions during the review. Many businesses struggle with the required meticulous record-keeping, worried about the consequences of discrepancies between reported data and actual operations.

What Is Personal Auto Insurance and What Does It Cover?

Workers’ compensation policy premiums are based on several factors, but the biggest is the size of your total payroll. When you apply for a workers’ comp insurance policy, you tell the insurer how much you expect to pay your employees during the upcoming year and what kinds of jobs you think they’ll be doing. Staying on top of payroll data, job descriptions, and subcontractor documents all year means you’re prepared when the auditor shows up. It can be as simple as setting up a regular check-in with your team to update records or creating a folder specifically for audit-related information. With everything organized, you’ll not only make the audit process smoother but also keep your costs in check. Preparing early gives you confidence that there won’t be any unpleasant surprises when the results come in.

How Does a Workers’ Comp Audit Work?

• Instead of guessing, you pay as you go—making it a great fit for industries like construction or restaurants, where payroll fluctuates a lot.
• Our team offers detailed guidance on navigating the complexities of insurance coverage, from foundational protection strategies to the latest trends in business and commercial insurance.
• If it’s an on-site audit, an auditor will pay you a visit to review records and take a look at your operations firsthand.
• When you first set up a workers’ comp policy, the premium is usually based on estimated numbers—things like payroll totals and the types of jobs employees are doing.

The audit helps both you and the insurance provider stay on the same page about what your job positions in the company are and payroll for each updated on the policy currently in force. Worker’s compensation is one of the few remaining policies that if your payroll is less than what you projected, you will get premium returned. So, while an audit might seem like a hassle, it’s really about keeping things balanced and ensuring your payroll matches your policy. We encourage you to help your client feel more comfortable with the final audit process by letting them know it’s a standard part of the workers’ comp process and not a penalty.

Accurate data ensures that the premiums reflect the true risk of the insured business, maintaining fairness and financial stability within the insurance system. This process not only protects the insurance carrier but also ensures that businesses are not overpaying or underpaying for their coverage. During the audit, the auditor will review payroll records and job classifications, checking that all records are accurate and complete. They may also interview staff to verify information and ensure that employee classifications align with their actual duties. For example, an auditor might ask a foreman to explain the duties of different workers to ensure that they are properly classified.

How Much Does Workers’ Comp Insurance Cost?

• The audit helps both you and the insurance provider stay on the same page about what your job positions in the company are and payroll for each updated on the policy currently in force.
• In that case, you’ll have to pay an additional premium to cover the difference.
• If you have reason to believe your final report is incorrect, start by reviewing the response line by line to identify any discrepancies.
• You can also consult with the insurance agent providing your workers’ compensation policy to discuss best dispute practices.

Often auditors request information on company financials in addition to payroll details. This article aimed to provide a comprehensive overview of what to expect during a workers’ compensation audit. It covered the purpose, types, and triggers for audits, as well as detailed the audit process and how to prepare for it.

Company

Once they have completed the audit, you will receive a final audit report that shows if you had more or less payroll than on your policy, resulting in an audit bill or refund. Our pay-as-you-go workers’ compensation solution allows you to automate insurance payments based on payroll. With our tools, business leaders can eliminate large down payments and avoid end-of-year surprises. We can even help you find the top-rated insurance carriers to keep you and your team covered. Workers’ compensation audits don’t have to be stressful if you stay organized throughout the year. Keeping accurate payroll records, properly classifying employees, and ensuring subcontractors have valid insurance will make the process much smoother.

A workers’ compensation audit can help you identify areas of improvement for the coming year. For example, it might be necessary to update employee classifications, upgrade your payroll software, or establish a better system for record keeping. Consult with your payroll company and insurance broker, as they may advise small changes that can make a big difference. The primary goal of a workers’ comp audit is to verify that your business paid the correct insurance premium over the last year. It helps prevent fraud and miscalculation, and serves as a guideline for rates in the coming year. ‍It ensures businesses pay the correct insurance premium based on actual payroll and job classifications.

Misclassifying employees—whether accidentally or intentionally—can lead to incorrect premium charges and potential penalties. This insurance also protects employers by preventing employees who are receiving workers’ comp benefits from suing their employers over injuries. This saves employers from costly legal battles and paying medical costs out of pocket. Workers’ comp coverage helps employees who get injured at work by covering their medical bills and paying them wages if they can’t work because of their injuries. At the end of the audit, you’ll receive the findings along with any recommended adjustments. If adjustments are needed, you’ll either be billed for the additional premium or, if you overpaid, you might get a refund.

For example, if underreported payroll is discovered, the report will specify the additional premium due and provide a deadline for payment. Reviewing the report carefully is crucial for understanding any changes to your premium and ensuring that all discrepancies have been accurately addressed. Once your insurance audit is complete, they will send a Final Audit Statement outlining any adjustments (additional premiums due) or credits (refunds received). Your agent should have informed you how your workers’ compensation policy operates at its inception – but if not, ask now about what this entails. Running any small business is a challenge, and that challenge is magnified when you have to pay and manage employees. Regardless of your business operations, most states require workers’ compensation insurance, so the burden also falls on you, the small business owner, to make sure your employees are protected.

Key Documents and Records to Gather

What actually happened for you is the year was a bit slow (bummer), and you didn’t hire as many pancake-makers as you thought you would. When your insurance company conducts its audit, it will see that you paid only $160,000 in actual payroll over the policy period. The insurance company will then cut you a check because you overpaid for the insurance premium on your workers’ compensation policy. State-specific regulations play a role in shaping workers’ compensation audits, affecting everything from required coverage on workers comp audit sole proprietors, officers, or partners and the documentation needed. Penalties for noncompliance also vary by state, sometimes involving steep fines or even legal action, making compliance crucial. Additionally, states have unique classification codes that influence how employee roles are categorized and how premiums are calculated.

Businesses often make a few key mistakes during workers’ comp audits that can lead to higher premiums. Common pitfalls include providing inaccurate payroll estimates, misclassifying employees, and missing allowable payroll deductions like severance or overtime adjustments. Another frequent error is failing to provide valid certificates for subcontractors, which can cause their payments to be added to payroll. Incomplete paperwork and not adjusting overtime pay correctly are also common issues. Finally, businesses often overlook state-specific rules or fail to communicate effectively with auditors.

They can clarify any questions you have regarding the audit, documentation required, or areas of potential confusion. If you disagree with the audit findings, you can challenge them by following the procedure outlined in the auditor’s report. This typically involves providing additional documentation to support your case and explaining any discrepancies in detail.

Workers’ Compensation Insurance Overview

Your insurance carrier will go over your premium payments and compare them to the estimates you provided at the start of the policy period. The goal is to ensure that your payments accurately reflect your payroll costs and your level of risk. A workers’ comp audit is a tool used by insurance companies to verify that your business has paid the appropriate amount throughout the expired policy period.

Insurers may estimate payroll at a higher rate, leading to increased premiums. Additionally, non-compliance could result in policy cancellation or legal penalties, leaving a business exposed to significant financial risks. Workers’ comp audits are essential for adjusting any discrepancies between the estimated and actual payroll figures that are used to calculate your insurance premiums. At the start of each insurance period, you provide an estimate of your total payroll. However, predicting these exact amounts can be tricky and often don’t quite match up by year’s end.

Workers’ compensation audits are enforced by virtually every insurance carrier, as these companies are often required by law to perform them in order to ensure compliance. Check out Huckleberry today for your workers’ compensation coverage and all other small business insurance needs. To stay informed on state-specific workers’ compensation laws, regularly check your state’s workers’ compensation board website for updates, as they provide official changes in regulations. Subscribing to industry newsletters or publications can also deliver timely insights.

For example, have payroll summaries, timesheets, and tax returns ready and organized. Being prepared reduces the likelihood of issues during the audit and ensures that the auditor can quickly and efficiently review all necessary information. The duration of the audit depends on the size and complexity of the business. Smaller businesses with straightforward payroll structures may only need a few hours, while larger companies with complex payrolls and multiple job classifications may take several days. For example, a small bakery might complete an audit in half a day, whereas a large construction firm might require a full week to review all records and verify classifications. The auditor will provide an estimate of the time required, but be prepared for the audit to take longer if discrepancies are found.

If your records are inaccurate or if employee roles aren’t properly classified, you might end up with a premium adjustment that catches you off guard. For instance, if you’ve overestimated payroll, you might get a refund, but if you underestimated, you could be looking at a bigger bill. When it’s time for a workers’ comp audit, an auditor will reach out to review your records. This might happen in person, where they visit your office, or it could be done remotely through a secure online system. The main goal here is for the auditor to make sure that your payroll records, employee classifications, and any other relevant information line up with what’s in your policy. Once the auditor has all the information they need, they’ll start examining the documents and records you’ve provided.

Instead of guessing, you pay as you go—making it a great fit for industries like construction or restaurants, where payroll fluctuates a lot. Since different jobs come with different levels of risk, job descriptions are key. These descriptions show the types of work your employees do, which helps in classifying roles. For example, an office worker has a different risk level than a construction worker and getting this right can prevent unnecessary audit corrections and disputes. This might involve video conferences, phone calls, and sharing documents electronically.